Curious about the people who were telling us to change our way
of life because of a changing climate, I decided to research one qualification of the authors of one of the most recent IPCC reports. The qualification I chose was the fields in which they were
It seemed odd that the most prevalent field of study among the group was economics.
A fair number included physics degrees in their biographies.
A few studied philosophy.
I did find
one person who had been schooled as a meteorologist. and one with a PhD in climate science. The next
most relative was PhD in atmospheric chemistry. It seemed odd to me that these were all listed as draft contributing authors.
There were none
that I could find other than that one who had the word climate any place in their education histories. There were no degrees in geology, climatology, paleoclimatology, atmospheric
dynamics, solar physics, historical climatology or geophysics.
Granted, they are a very scholarly and well published group that are deserving of a lot of respect, but why are there not a lot of actual climate scientists amongst the lot. Could it be that most of those who have actually studied in the field
are not convinced of the dangers of a warming climate.
There is no doubt that these are very intelligent and well educated people and that their opinions are valuable, but when it come down to it, they seem to be commenting outside of their expertise.
In the end it is only their opinion and perhaps not an adequate base for spending trillions of dollars of tax payer money or making massive disruptive changes to global society.
In Wikipedia there is published a list of scientists, each with credentials in one or more climate science disciplines. I am certain it is not complete, and many bona fide climate scientists are likely omitted. What is notable is that, not a single one is on the list of
authors posted here. Nor is a single one of the authors on the wiki list.
What follows is a list of the authors with their individual education histories. It is not 100% complete but is as close as I could get with a couple of days research. This information
is not guaranteed as to accuracy and I apologize if I got the wrong person when searching or if I have made other errors. Most of the list is copy and paste, so there may be other errors for which I am not responsible. I encourage anyone who cares to, to do
their own research or to expand on mine.
- economist -Diploma in Economics with honors at the - completed his PhD in Economics with summa cum laude at the Technical University of Darmstadtin 1999 under the supervision
of Carlo Jaeger-belonged the Jesuit Order from 1987–1994 and
earned a bachelor's degree in Philosophy with summa cum laude at the Munich School of Philosophy.
Ramón Pichs Madruga- bachelor's degree in economics from 1989 to 1991 at the University of Lund, where he completed a Master's degree in social sciences.
Youba Sokona - Found no references as to education - He has published several books and articles on the issues of energy, environment and development with a focus on Africa. Does not seem to
have a background in science.
Shardul Agrawala - economist received his PhD from Princeton University
Alexeyevich Bashmakov - could find no references to science background or education. This link describes his experience
- Graduated from the College of Engineering of the Universidad Nacional de Buenos Aires, Argentina, in 1989, and from University of Massachusetts, USA, as a Master of Science in renewable
energy systems in 2001.
John Broome - John Broome is a British philosopher
and economist primary interest is ethics. Could not find any other background in science.
Thomas Bruckner -
completed his doctoral studies in theoretical physics at the University of Würzburg, Germany.
Steffen Brunner ---very elusive credentials – is associated with Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research- unsure of the credentials of that institution.
- Mercedes Bustamente holds a BSc in Biology, an MSc in Plant Physiology and a PhD in Geobotany.
Leon Clarke - Dr. Clarke holds Ph.D. and M.S. degrees in Engineering Economic Systems and Operations Research from Stanford
University and B.S. and M.S. degrees in Mechanical Engineering from U.C. Berkeley.
Creutzig - received his PhD in Computational Neuroscience from Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, and holds a Master of Advanced Studies (Path III in Mathematics)
from Cambridge University, UK.
Shobhakar Dhakal - Ph. D. Energy and Urban Heat Island Mitigation, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo M. Eng. Energy economics and planning, Asian Institute of Technology, Thailand B. Engg. Electrical
Engineering, National Institute of Technology Surat, India.
Navroz K. Dubash - Dr Dubash holds an MA and PhD in energy and resources from the University of California, Berkeley, and an AB in public and international affairs from Princeton University.
Patrick Eickemeier - Another one that was difficult
to find information on. His background appears to be in ecology and biology.
Ellie Farahan - M.B.A., Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University, Evanston,
IL, USA, 2008 - Ph.D., Experimental Atmospheric Physics, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada 2006.
Manfred Fischedick - University of Dortmund, Germany. University Diploma
in Chemical Engineering . Doctorate in the field of Energy Technology at University of Stuttgart, Germany.
Marc Fleurbaey - Fleurbay
received a Maîtrise in Philosophy from University of Paris X in 1991, and a Ph.D. in Economics from Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (EHESS), Paris in 1994.
Reyer Gerlagh - In 1999 Reyer Gerlagh received
his PhD in economics.
Luis Gómez-Echeverri - He was educated at Yale University and Georgetown
University, both in the USA, in the areas of environmental science and international economic affairs respectively.
Sujata Gupta - Ph.D.
London Business School. Affiliation, Asian development bank. (I believe this is the
Jochen Harnisch - He has a degree of atmospheric physics from the University of Göttingen.
Kejun Jiang - He received his Ph.D in Social Engineering from the Department of Tokyo Institute of Technology.
Susanne Kadner - PhD? Experience in Oceanography, Analytical Chemistry, Microbiology.
Sivan Kartha - Ph.D. in theoretical physics from Cornell University in 1993.
Stephan Klasen - He holds a BA, MA, and Ph.D. from Harvard University. In what fields is unclear but his focus seems to be on population, labor, welfare, and development economics.
Charles Kolstad - environmental
economist with a focus on industrial organization and public economics. Kolstad holds a Ph.D. from Stanford, an MA.. in mathematics from the University of Rochester, and a B.A. in mathematics from Bates College.
Krey - Volker Krey graduated in theoretical physics from the University of Dortmund (Germany) in 2002. Since 2006, he has held a PhD in mechanical engineering
from the Ruhr-University of Bochum (Germany).
- 1959, AB, Bates College; 1965, PhD, Massachusetts Institute
of Technology. Unclear as to field of study.
Oswaldo Lucon - PhD (Energy), MSc (Chem Proc Eng), Civ Eng, B Law.
Masera - Dr. Masera obtained his Masters and PhD. at the Energy and Resources Group, UC Berkeley in the area
of rural energy.
Jan Minx - Ph.D. in Environmental Economics and Management, Environment
Department, University of York, UK, M.Sc. in Environmental Economics, Environment Department,
University of York, UK.
Yacob Mulugetta- Professor of Energy and Development Policy, and Director of the MPA programme at the Department of Science, Technology, Engineering & Public
Policy, unable to find references as to education.
Anthony Patt - bachelor’s
degree in Architecture and Landscape Design at Yale University, After a few years practicing as a lawyer and consultant in environmental and policy issues, he applied
to Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, where he received a Master in Public Policy and in 2001 his doctorate.
Nijavalli H. Ravindranath - Broad areas of research and development include climate change, bioenergy
and biomass production, community forestry, environmental and ecosystems services and citizen science. Earlier education unclear.
Keywan Riahi - 1998‐2003: Doctoral Study: Dr. tech. In Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Management. 1989‐1997: Dipl. Ing. In Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Management.
Joyashree Roy - Professor of Economics, expertise in environmental economics. Could not find references to early education.
Roberto Schaeffer - He currently holds an Associate Professor position in Energy Economics. He holds
a Ph.D. in Energy Management and Policy from the University of Pennsylvania (USA, 1990).
Steffen Schlömer - He holds a diploma in economics (M.Sc. Equivalent).
Karen Seto - Ph.D., Geography, M.A., International Relations & Resource and Environmental Management, B.A., Political Science.
Kristin Seyboth - Seyboth received her Master of Science in Environmental Management and Policy at the International Institute for Industrial Environmental Economics, Lund University, Sweden and her Bachelor of Arts
in Biology from Bucknell University, USA.
Ralph Sims - Ralph Sims is Professor of Sustainable Energy, Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand. A chartered engineer. Could not find references to higher education.
Skea - Professor of sustainable energy at Imperial College London. Holds a BSc and a PhD, unclear in what fields.
Pete Smith - PhD, His main areas of expertise are in modelling greenhouse gas / carbon mitigation, bio-energy for fossil fuel offsets, and biological carbon sequestration.
Eswaran Somanathan - Ph. D., Economics (Harvard). Areas of interest: Environment and development,
evolutionary models of behavior.
Robert Stavins - He holds a B.A. in philosophy from Northwestern University, an M.S. in agricultural economics from Cornell, and a Ph.D. in economics
Christoph von Stechow - MA (European Studies), Diplom-Volkswirt, Energy Economics, Environmental Economics, Welfare Economics.
Thomas Sterner- Thomas Sterner is professor
of environmental economics.
Taishi Sugiyama - 1991 B. Science., Physics, 1993 M.
Eng., Applied Physics, The University of Tokyo.
Sangwon Suh - PhD, Environmental Science & Engineering, Leiden University (Netherlands); MS and BS, Environmental Engineering, Ajou University (South Korea).
Kevin Chika Urama - Professor Kevin Chika Urama holds a First Class Honors degree and a Master of Science in Agricultural Economics from the University of Nigeria, Nsukka, a Master of Philosophy degree with distinction, and a Ph.D. in Land Economy
from the University of Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Diana Ürge-Vorsatz - Doctorate in Environmental Science and Engineering 1992-1996 University of California, Los Angeles and Berkeley. Postgraduate
Program in Environmental Sciences Central European University (CEU), June-August 1992. Master of Science, Physics, 1986-92 (specialization: Astrophysics; later Environmental Physics) Eötvös Lóránd University of Sciences (ELTE), Budapest.
David G. Victor - 1997
Ph.D. (Political Science), MIT 1987, A.B. (History and Science), Harvard University.
Dadi Zhou - Dr. Dadi holds Bachelors and Masters degrees in Physics and Engineering from
Tsinghua University in Beijing in 1970 and 1982 respectively and a PhD from Geneva College of Diplomacy and International Relations in Geneva, Switzerland.
Zou - Could not find references to education.
is in physics (PhD), artificial intelligence (MSc) and neuroscience.
Draft Contributing Authors
Giovanni Baiocchi - Dr. Giovanni Baiocchi is an applied environmental economist. He holds a PhD.
Helena Chum - Ph.D. 1972 University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil (Physical Chemistry),
B.S. 1968 University of São Paulo (Chemistry with Industrial Specialization), B.S. 1968 University of São Paulo (Chemical Education).
Jan Fuglestvedt - Ph.D. in atmospheric chemistry, University of Oslo, Master
of Science in environmental chemistry, University of Oslo.
Helmut Haberl - Doctorate in Ecology, University of Vienna 1995; Master in Biology and Mathematics, University of Vienna, 1989).
- Hertwich earned a PhD in energy and resources from the University of California, Berkeley, in the USA.
Kriegler - Elmar Kriegler received a diploma (MS equivalent) degree in physics from the Albert-Ludwigs-University
of Freiburg, Germany, in 1998, and a PhD degree in physics from the University of Potsdam, Germany, in 2005.
Rogelj - He holds a PhD in climate science from ETH Zurich, Switzerland, and Master's degree in Engineering and Development Studies from KU Leuven, Belgium.
H.-Holger Rogner -
Dr. H-Holger Rogner holds an MSc in industrial engineering (1975) and a PhD in energy economics (1981).
Michiel Schaeffer - Dr Michiel Schaeffer is a biophysicist
and received his PhD in Dynamic Meteorology at University of Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Steven J. Smith -
Ph.D., Physics, University of California, Los Angeles. I am not 100% sure this is the right Dr. Smith.
van Vuuren - Utrecht University, Master of Science Chemistry, Master of Science Environmental Sciences, PhD Energy systems and climate policy.
Ryan Wiser - Ryan holds a B.S. in Civil Engineering from Stanford University and an M.S. and Ph.D. in Energy and Resources from the University of California, Berkeley.